OP-ED: The IOC Wrong Again: Munich Victims Should be Honored

  • By Evan Weiner  
Bob Costas

Bob Costas

Note from David M. Kinchen of Huntington News Network: This commentary below,


was reprinted by permission of the author, Evan Weiner. In a related matter, Bob Costas of NBC Sports, the anchor commentator at the London games, has decided to honor the slain athletes at the opening ceremonies on Friday, July 27. According to The Hollywood Reporter, under the headline:

“Bob Costas Takes Olympics to Task for Denying Israel’s Munich Massacre Moment of Silence”

“The NBC sportscaster calls the decision ‘baffling’.

“When the London games officially launch July 27, Bob Costas will stage his own protest of what he calls a ‘baffling’ decision: the NBC sportscaster plans to call out the International Olympic Committee for denying Israel’s request for a moment of silence acknowledging the massacre of 11 Israeli athletes and coaches at the 1972 Games.

“‘I intend to note that the IOC denied the request,’ he tells THR. ‘Many people find that denial more than puzzling but insensitive. Here’s a minute of silence right now.’

“Costas intends to make his remarks during the Olympics’ Opening Ceremony, which coincides with the 40th anniversary of the Munich massacre, when the Israeli delegation enters the 80,000-seat Olympic Stadium.

“Costas, an opinionated yet authoritative voice in the world of sports, has support from his former producer, Dick Ebersol, who says: ‘There’s a reality in business; there were times when I thought he got too forceful. But I’m very proud of the fact that Bob was able to be Bob.'”

* * *

By Evan Weiner

photo credit: AP/Getty Images

photo credit: AP/Getty Images…Israeli athletes at Sept. 6, 1972 memorial service

You can always count on the International Olympic Committee to be on the wrong side of common decency. The group, which has permanent observer status — a designation that only the Vatican at the United Nations was ever given, has once again come up short. The International Olympic Committee’s President Dr. Jacques Rogge has confirmed there will not be a minute’s silence at the London 2012 Opening Ceremony in honor of the 11 Israeli athletes killed during the 1972 Munich Olympics.

Dr. Rogge has in essence continued in the tradition of former International Olympic Committee President Avery Brundage who following the massacre in 1972 proclaimed “the Games must go on.”

The International Olympic Committee and the five interlocking rings logo seems to have a hypnotizing impact on people. It’s the Olympics, we have to watch, it is all about patriotism and rooting for our guys and our girls. The feeling of pride swelling inside when our athletes stand on the podium and get a gold medal (which isn’t made of gold) and then the national anthem is played.

But the real Olympics is not shown on a stage where the world can see. It’s a backroom game where money and power trump athleticism.

Very few people have ever stood up to the Olympics power. In 1935 Ernest Lee Jahncke and Jeremiah Mahoney pushed for an American boycott of the 1936 Berlin Summer Games. Neither succeeded but Jahncke inadvertently opened the door which led to Avery Brundage becoming a key figure in both the United States Olympics movement and the International Olympics Committee.

Jahncke, who was an American International Olympic Committee delegate, expressed outrage with reports of what was happening within Hitler’s Germany and on November 25, 1935 sent a letter to IOC President Count Henri Bailet Lator floating the initial idea of an American boycott of the 1936 Berlin Summer Games.

“Neither Americans nor the representatives of other countries can take part in the Games in Nazi Germany without at least acquiescing in the contempt of the Nazis for fair play and their sordid exploitation of the Games.”

The letter seemed to go unanswered.

Jahncke, who was a former assistant secretary for the United States Navy and was of German descent, was thrown out of the exclusive club known as the International Olympic Committee by July 1936 and his spot was taken by Brundage. 
Jahncke wasn’t the only one who called for an American boycott of the 1936 Berlin Games. In December, 1935, the president of the United States Amateur Athletic Union (AAU) Judge Jeremiah Mahoney recommended that America drop out of the Berlin Games. A number of United States Catholic leaders joined with Mahoney including New York Governor. Al Smith and Massachusetts Governor James Curley calling for a boycott.
Avery Brundage, who was the president of the American Olympic Committee, got the votes he needed to repel Mahoney and the American team went to Berlin. Brundage felt there was no need for the Olympics to be part of the political world and that the German government would treat Jewish athletes fairly.

Two Jewish athletes, runners Marty Glickman and Sam Stoller, never competed in their 4 x 4 relay. Glickman spent the rest of his life explaining that Brundage pulled him and Stoller from the race because Brundage wanted to spare Adolf Hitler the embarrassment of seeing two Jews on the podium receiving gold medals.

Brundage was a member of the America First Committee. That group advocated an anti-war sentiment and urged America to take hands off approach on policy with regards to Germany to the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941.

In the 1970s Brundage called the 1936 Berlin Games the finest ever.

Brundage would eventually become the International Olympics Committee president and presided over the 1972 Munich Games where the terrorist attack took place and 11 Israeli athletes were murdered in the Olympic village.

The athletic event, which was supposed to not be part of the political world, was politicized. Brundage suspended the Games for a day and then made a rambling speech which included the phrase “the Games must go on.” That was the last time the Olympics movement acknowledged what happened in Germany in 1972.

The modern day Olympics are fully immersed in the real world. The Berlin or Hitler Olympics was politically charged. President Franklin Roosevelt urged the American team to go to the Berlin Games knowing full well about the strangling of Jewish rights in Germany. The 1940 Olympics Summer Games were canceled. That event was supposed to have taken place in Tokyo.

The outbreak of World War II in 1939 finished off the Tokyo Games.
In 1968, Brundage expelled two Americans, John Carlos and Thommie Smith, from the Olympics village in Mexico City after the pair raised their fists in a “Black Power” salute to protest black poverty after they won a gold and silver medal in an event. Brundage, by that time, was the International Olympics Committee president and detested political interaction with the Olympics playground.

Of course the Olympics movement is loaded with political ammunition. The 1976 Montreal Games had a twofold problem. A good many African countries boycotted the festivities because New Zealand was not barred from the event. A New Zealand rugby team played in South Africa and the African countries felt that New Zealand should not have allowed that team to play in apartheid South Africa.

The apolitical Olympics that Brundage led was hypocritical. On August 18, 1964 South Africa was formally banned from the Tokyo Olympics for failing to rid itself of being an apartheid state.

The Montreal Games nearly ended the Olympics with the enormous cost attached to the building of facilities to host the event. Only Los Angeles bid for the 1984 Games as no community wanted to pay for the Games. The United States Olympic Committee pushed for a Denver, Colorado based 1976 Winter Olympics but Colorado voters said no by a 3 to 2 margin because of the potential cost of the Games after the Munich Massacre in November 1972.

It was the first time Americans stood up to Brundage and the IOC.

Brundage became the International Olympics Committee president in 1952.
The Munich Olympics was Brundage’s last as IOC President. In the 40 years since Brundage left office, the IOC has become far more political. Brundage wasn’t around for the United States and western countries boycott of the 1980 Moscow Games. United States President Jimmy Carter led the way and barred United States athletes from going to Moscow because of the Soviet Union’s invasion of Afghanistan. The Soviets and eastern bloc countries got payback by boycotting the 1984 Games.

There was a bombing at the 1996 Atlanta Games which killed one person. Years later, an anti-abortion activist was arrested and charged with the crime.

The Montreal Games hiked taxes in Montreal, Quebec and in Canada. The bill was finally paid in full in 2006 and cost taxpayers billions. Peter Ueberroth commercialized the 1984 Los Angeles Games and sold everything he could to corporate sponsors for big money. Other Olympic organizing committees went to school on the 1984 LA business plan.

The International Olympics Committee got politically savvy and sold the Games as a way to improve an area’s infrastructure. Barcelona’s 1992 Games included building up the city’s port. Politicians use the Olympics as the excuse to upgrade areas, of course, they could do that without an event but don’t.

But it is very difficult to tell that there was an Olympics in Atlanta in 1996 except for the leftover sports facilities. The Georgia Dome, which was opened about 20 years ago and played a role in the 1996 Games, is now considered obsolete for use by a National Football League team. The Atlanta Falcons ownership wants a new facility in the city which goes to show that facilities have a very short shelf life.

The 2002 Salt Lake City Games was marred by an IOC bid rigging scandal. Bain Capital CEO Mitt Romney left his company or maybe he didn’t leave his company to run those Games. Romney needed cash in a hurry to help bridge the Salt Lake City money shortfall and turned to Washington to get federal funding.
Romney should not be criticized for that. He was doing what the heads of local Olympic committees do. The IOC demands that any cost overruns associated with the building of facilities for an Olympics is paid for by the local city, state or national governments. That’s the way the game is played. You want an Olympics and you lose money, that’s not an IOC problem, that’s a your problem.

It is estimated that United States taxpayers bailed out the Salt Lake City Games to the tune of $1.5 billion.

Australian taxpayers are stuck with the bills from the 2000 Sydney Games. Greece was not bankrupted by hosting the 2004 Summer Olympics in Athens but the more than $10 billion worth of debt hasn’t helped the Greek economy. Turin no longer is prospering following the 2006 Winter Olympics in the Italian city. No one knows what the 2008 Beijing Games cost, but that was a loss leader for China as China got onto the world economic stage because of the Games while whitewashing human rights violations.

There is no real bill from the financially stressed Vancouver Winter Games in 2010 but locals are not happy with the debt piled up by those events. London may be a financial disaster when the bills from the Games that open up on Friday come due.

This is the real Olympics.

The sad part is that for the majority of the athletes this is their time to shine in the sun. Most of them have to pay their way there and struggle to find money while they train. But to the IOC they are a disposable commodity. The way athletes are now judged at the Olympics isn’t by the amount of medals they win or even competing.

No, it is how many endorsements can an athlete get from competing. In America, athletes become storylines on TV and most events are ignored. The truth is ping pong will get more global viewers than an American soap opera story. But TV wants women to watch and if they can build a storyline, which, they think, will suck women into watching the proceedings.

American television pays the bulk of the money that goes to the IOC.

Dr. Jacques Rogge won’t do the right thing and honor the murdered Israeli athletes. Politically it is probably unwise considering the make-up of the International Olympics Committee. But you can always count on the International Olympics Committee to be on the wrong side of an issue whether it is criminal prosecution of athletes caught with banned substances–it is not a crime, it is cheating—leaving a community in fiscal straits or deviating from a program and remembering a sorrowful event that happened on their clock.


* * *

Evan Weiner, the winner of the United States Sports Academy’s 2010 Ronald Reagan Media Award, is an author, radio-TV commentator and speaker on “The Politics of Sports Business.” He can be reachedatevanjweiner@gmail.com. His book, “The Business and Politics of Sports, Second Edition” is availableatwww.bickley.com and Amazon


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: